Last Friday at 1600 no less, in a town about 40 miles from home, Stephenville, TX, I met with my new audiologist provided by the VA. He is part of the Livingston chain of hearing aid suppliers in Texas. Everything went as expected as far as assessment etc. Yes, I need new hearing aids – yeah! But in my case, he recommended in-ear rechargeable ones. He took impressions of both of my ear canals with a substance in a tube that felt like caulking for windows. Except it solidified in a short period and he was able to completely remove the impressions in one fell swoop. He said he had to obtain approval from the VA which would take up to a month and we’d go from there. He also said that I would be seeing him quarterly hereafter to ensure my hearing was attended to. This is something new.
This leads to the question “How do over-the-ear aids compare to in-ear aids?” To addresses this query, I turned to Poe again with the following results:
Prompt: Recently my audiologist prescribed an in-ear hearing aid for me for which he took impressions of both of my ear canals. Describe in some detail the differences between an over-the-ear hearing aid and a rechargeable one that fits in the ear canal. Positive and negatives, please.
DoctorSage Poe
Certainly! Let’s compare the differences between an over-the-ear (OTE) hearing aid and a rechargeable in-the-ear (ITE) hearing aid that fits in the ear canal. Both types of hearing aids have their own advantages and disadvantages. Here’s a detailed overview:
Over-the-ear (OTE) Hearing Aid:
Positive aspects:
Amplification power: OTE hearing aids tend to have larger batteries and more space for advanced technology, allowing for higher amplification power and better sound processing capabilities.
Comfort and fit: OTE hearing aids rest behind the ear, making them suitable for individuals with different ear canal sizes. They are generally more comfortable to wear and cause less occlusion (blocked feeling) in the ear canal.
Durability and maintenance: Due to their larger size, OTE hearing aids are often more robust and less prone to damage. They are easier to clean and maintain.
Negative aspects:
Visibility: Some individuals may feel self-conscious about wearing a visible hearing aid since OTE devices are more noticeable than those that fit inside the ear canal.
Wind noise: OTE hearing aids may be more susceptible to wind noise, which can affect sound quality during outdoor activities.
Feedback: Since the microphone and receiver are located outside the ear, the possibility of feedback (whistling sound) is slightly higher compared to ITE hearing aids.
Rechargeable In-the-Ear (ITE) Hearing Aid:
Positive aspects:
Cosmetics: ITE hearing aids are custom-made to fit the shape of the individual’s ear canal, making them discreet and less noticeable.
Convenience: Rechargeable ITE hearing aids eliminate the need for frequent battery changes. They usually come with a portable charging case that allows for easy and on-the-go charging.
Sound quality: ITE hearing aids can provide a more natural sound perception since they are placed closer to the eardrum, allowing for better sound localization and improved directionality.
Negative aspects:
Battery life: Rechargeable ITE hearing aids typically have a shorter battery life compared to traditional disposable battery-powered devices. However, advancements in technology have led to longer-lasting rechargeable batteries.
Size limitations: Due to the size constraints of the ear canal, ITE hearing aids may have limited space for advanced features and larger batteries, potentially impacting the availability of certain high-end functionalities.
Maintenance: ITE hearing aids require regular cleaning and maintenance to avoid wax build-up and ensure optimal performance. They may be more susceptible to damage from moisture and earwax.
It’s important to note that the choice between an OTE hearing aid and a rechargeable ITE hearing aid depends on several factors, including the individual’s hearing loss, lifestyle, personal preference, and the recommendation of the audiologist. A thorough evaluation by an audiologist will help determine the most suitable type of hearing aid for your specific needs.
If you have any further questions or need more specific information, please let me know!
Can you explain how the sound quality of an over-the-ear hearing aid compares to a rechargeable in-the-ear hearing aid?
DoctorSage Poe
Certainly! When comparing the sound quality of an over-the-ear (OTE) hearing aid to a rechargeable in-the-ear (ITE) hearing aid, there are a few factors to consider:
Amplification and Power: OTE hearing aids generally have more space for advanced technology, including larger batteries and amplifiers. This allows for higher amplification power and more sophisticated sound processing capabilities. As a result, OTE devices can often provide a broader frequency response range and more precise sound amplification, which may contribute to improved sound quality.
Proximity to the Ear: ITE hearing aids, being placed directly in the ear canal, can provide a more natural sound perception since the sound is delivered closer to the eardrum. This proximity can enhance sound localization and improve the ability to perceive subtle nuances in speech and environmental sounds. The closer positioning of the microphone and receiver in ITE devices can also reduce the possibility of sound distortion or interference.
Sound Occlusion: OTE hearing aids are positioned behind the ear, which generally results in less occlusion or a blocked feeling in the ear canal. In contrast, ITE hearing aids occupy a portion of the ear canal, potentially leading to a slight occlusion effect. This occlusion may affect the perception of one’s own voice, low-frequency sounds, and overall sound quality. However, modern ITE hearing aids are designed to minimize occlusion and provide more natural sound experiences.
Personalization and Customization: Both types of hearing aids can be programmed and adjusted to an individual’s specific hearing needs. However, ITE hearing aids, being custom-made to fit the shape of the ear canal, can offer a more personalized and tailored fit. This customized fit may improve sound delivery and localization, contributing to a better overall sound experience.
It is important to note that the perception of sound quality is subjective and can vary from person to person based on individual preferences and needs. Factors such as the degree and type of hearing loss, the specific technology and features of the hearing aids, and the expertise of the audiologist in fitting and programming the devices can all influence the perceived sound quality.
Ultimately, the choice between an OTE hearing aid and a rechargeable ITE hearing aid should be based on a comprehensive evaluation by an audiologist, taking into consideration the individual’s hearing profile, lifestyle, and personal preferences.
Leave a Reply